• About
  • Press
  • Advertise

Craft Test Dummies

The Crafting Blog for Crafters, By Crafters

  • Craft News
    • CHA Coverage
    • Crafting for a Cause
    • Giveaways
    • CTD on TV
    • Quilt Market
  • Craft Product Reviews
    • Apps & Sites
    • Art Supplies/Mixed Media
    • Beads/Jewelry Products
    • Books, Magazines, Events
    • Comparisons
    • Crafty Tools
    • Fabric, Needle, & Quilting Arts
    • Food Crafts
    • Paints, Inks & Dyes
    • Paper Crafts
    • Polymer Clay & Tools
  • Craft Storage and Tips
  • Crafty People & Places
    • Crafty Field Trips
  • Kids Stuff
    • Hands On Crafts For Kids-TV show
  • Winter/Christmas
  • Home Decor
  • Food Crafting/ Party Crafts
  • Valentine’s /Sweetest Day
  • Spring/Easter
  • Wedding & Shower Crafts
  • Father’s Day Crafts
  • Baby & Shower Crafts
  • Mother’s Day Crafts
  • Patriotic crafts
  • Summer Crafts
  • Fall Crafts
    • Halloween Crafts
  • Jenny Sez
    • Sponsored Posts
  • Periscope Superfans Page
Home / Craft Product Reviews / art supplies/mixed media / Distress Crayons Vs. Gelatos- a Comparison!

Distress Crayons Vs. Gelatos- a Comparison!

April 4, 2016

Everyone wants to know what is the difference between Ranger’s Distress Crayons and Faber-Castell Gelatos? I am not endorsing one over the other, but you should know that there are some differences in colors, pigment content, and packaging that might influence your purchasing decision.

Everyone wants to know what is the difference between Ranger's Distress Crayons and Faber-Castell Gelatos? Well, I show you here in SIX MINUTES and 10 examples of how they are the same...and different! I am not endorsing one over the other, but you should know that there are some differences in colors, pigment content, and packaging that might influence your purchasing decision.

Disclosure: samples were provided by both companies for review purposes. Opinions are my own and based on my first-hand experience with the products.

Well, I show you here in SIX MINUTES and 10 examples of how they are the same…and different!

Here are those photos again:

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Size matters- you get more product for a cheaper price point with the Gelatos.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Water sprinkled on top, then dabbed off with a paper towel.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Product applied then blended out with a baby wipe.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Product applied directly to a rubber stamp and then misted with water. First stamp at the bottom, second in the middle and last on top.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Product dipped in water and then scribbled on watercolor paper misted with water.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Product applied on watercolor paper, stencil laid on top, then wiped gently with a baby wipe.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Wet paintbrush dragged through product.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Product on black textured paper.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Stamped with Tuxedo Black Memento stamp pad and then allowed to air dry for 10 minutes. Distress Crayons smeared.

Distress Crayons versus Gelatos: a head-to-head comparision

Products applied to white gesso stenciled background.

So here’s my takeaways:

  • Gelatos have more opaque color
  • Gelatos blend more
  • Gelatos work better on dark/black surfaces
  • Gelatos give you more product for less money
  • Gelatos have more colors and include pearls and metallics in the line
  • Distress Crayons match other Distress products
  • Distress Crayons apply very smoothly
  • Distress Crayons have a nice easy-grip pen-style package
  • Distress Crayons “move” less and layer well
  • Distress Crayons remove more easily on gesso’d surfaces

And while prices vary, on Amazon.com 18 Distress Crayons sell for $37, while 12 Gelatos sell for $19.99. That makes them approximately $3 each for Distress, while Gelatos are a thrifty $1.60 each. And there is more product inside! So if you are thrifty, Gelatos may be the best bet for you- but if you are a Distress fan, you are going to want these colors in your craft box!

What do you think? Which product is right for you?

 

  • About the Author
  • Latest Posts

About Jenny

Chief Craft Test Dummy, Craft Evangelist, Founder, Editor, bottle-washer, trouble-maker, and creative whirlwind.
  • Spooky Spider Halloween Bookmark Craft - October 24, 2018
  • Review and Demo of LDRS Hybrid Ink Pads - October 15, 2018
  • Review and Demo of Nuvo Hybrid Inks - October 1, 2018
  • Craft Studio Tour and Organization Ideas - September 20, 2018
  • Wax Paper Resist Background Technique - March 20, 2018
  • Comparison of Liquid Watercolor Markers/Pens - March 16, 2018
  • SAI Japanese Traditional Watercolor Brush Markers- Review & Demo - February 23, 2018
  • Rinea Metallic Foil Paper & Ghost Ink Review - February 21, 2018
  • Jane Davenport debuts at Creativation 2018 & Watercolor Card - February 13, 2018
  • Creativation 2018: New Product Showcase - January 20, 2018

Posted in art supplies/mixed media, Comparisons |

Comments

  1. Kate says

    April 4, 2016 at 11:37

    Thanks for the review. I hadn’t been all that impressed with the Distress crayons (all the demonstrations seemed to require a layer of gesso first), but I hadn’t thought about how well they would work if you already had a lot of the distress products.

    A better deal than Gelatos are the Faber-Castell – 12 Count- Gel Sticks for $9.95 and the Faber-Castell Metallic Gel Sticks 6ct for $7.91 (both at Amazon). I have both the gel stick and gelatos and when comparing the exact same colors, I can not tell the difference. The only advantage to the Gelatos is that there are more colors available. One thing I have noticed about both is that some colors go on as smooth as lipstick, others are crumbly, but all blend nicely with a finger.

    I also really like the Caran d’Ache Classic Neocolor II Water-Soluble Pastels (15 for $23.73 from Amazon). They can be purchased in sets or as open stock from an art store like Dick Blick. They look like crayons with a paper wrapper and are firmer than Gelatos, but go on smoothly and completely dissolve with a water brush, even on plain paper.

  2. kiki balden says

    April 29, 2016 at 15:33

    I’ve got the Gelatos starter pack and then saw the TH distress crayons and was quite upset thinking I had wasted money , but looking at your side by side samples I mostly prefer what the gelatos can do so thank you for these examples. I now know that what I bought will still do a great job!

  3. Cat says

    May 31, 2017 at 20:08

    Thanks for the comparison. This really helped in my researching which one to purchase.

ctd-headshot-round

Hi! I’m Jenny, the co-host of Hands On Crafts for Kids on PBS and the Head Dummy behind CraftTestDummies.com where you’ll find craft product reviews, tutorials, and craft industry news.

ctd-fb ctd-pin ctd-twitter cts-insta ctd-youtube ctd-g ctd-email

Search

ctd-subscribe
Want weekly craft projects delivered straight to your inbox?

YouTube

Disclosure

CraftTestDummies is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

jenny-headshot-square

Jenny Barnett Rohrs is Head Dummy and Pied Piper behind CTD, which focuses on reviews, tutorials, and craft industry news. Jenny has appeared on HSN, Scrapbook Soup PBS series, and is currently the co-host of Hands On Crafts for Kids on PBS.

ctd-fb-30  ctd-pin-30  ctd-twitter-30  cts-insta-30  ctd-youtube-30  ctd-g-30  ctd-email-30  ctd-rss-30

Copyrighted Content Permission All images and tutorials on this blog are copyrighted material. Please contact me if you would like to borrow any media (photos, video or audio files), tutorials, or ideas from this blog. 99% of the time I would be happy to allow you to use one photo with appropriate credit and link back to CraftTestDummies.com (preferably to the same post it was borrowed from.)
clever-network  linqia  viglink

All content copyright © 2015 Craft Test Dummies | Privacy Policy | Disclosures | Site design by XO Sarah

MENU
  • Craft News
    • CHA Coverage
    • Crafting for a Cause
    • Giveaways
    • CTD on TV
    • Quilt Market
  • Craft Product Reviews
    • Apps & Sites
    • Art Supplies/Mixed Media
    • Beads/Jewelry Products
    • Books, Magazines, Events
    • Comparisons
    • Crafty Tools
    • Fabric, Needle, & Quilting Arts
    • Food Crafts
    • Paints, Inks & Dyes
    • Paper Crafts
    • Polymer Clay & Tools
  • Craft Storage and Tips
  • Crafty People & Places
    • Crafty Field Trips
  • Kids Stuff
    • Hands On Crafts For Kids-TV show
  • Winter/Christmas
  • Home Decor
  • Food Crafting/ Party Crafts
  • Valentine’s /Sweetest Day
  • Spring/Easter
  • Wedding & Shower Crafts
  • Father’s Day Crafts
  • Baby & Shower Crafts
  • Mother’s Day Crafts
  • Patriotic crafts
  • Summer Crafts
  • Fall Crafts
    • Halloween Crafts
  • Jenny Sez
    • Sponsored Posts
  • Periscope Superfans Page